This is a time-honored dodge, which might be called “the Oompa-Loompa
defense.” It goes something like this: outsourcing labor to people who
will work for less is fine because they are “happy” to do it. Such
practices and accompanying rationales have been continually
refined—think the helpline that dials a tech in Bangalore. But the
fantasy of the happy worker has taken on newer and more mind-bending
aspects, as has work itself. It now includes things like the unpaid
microlabor of providing content for Web sites. It includes the amateur
photographer who provides her images of, say, the police killing a young
black man to the local news as an “iReport” for nothing but a credit
and a T-shirt. Or a music lover scratching out a review on some hip site
for a byline alone. Or consider the subtlest and arguably the most
exemplary case: how, in wandering the byways of Facebook and Google, you
are diligently rendering gratis a host of information about the
preferences and habits of you and your friends—data they sell to
advertisers. This, too, is unpaid labor.
In general, there is the boom in such practices that seems tied to
the digital era; you can’t spell Internet without intern. As the
argument goes, you are paid in access to a desirable milieu, or the
chance to do good. Work for nada at an N.G.O.: you are being paid in
justice itself. Oh, you might also get the vague promise that such
valuable experience will pay off later. This promise is packaged with
the threat that if you don’t take the gig, you will be closed out of the
disastrous job market altogether. You had better be happy about it.
Ideally, you don’t even know you are working at all. You think you
are keeping up with friends, or networking, or saving the world. Or
jamming with the band. And you are. But you are also laboring for
someone else’s benefit without getting paid.
- Joshua Clover
(and what did AFP take away from this? 'She said that, in the midst of the Kickstarter controversy, the New Yorker published an article "tearing me to pieces". It included "the basest, most cruel insult someone could throw at me, which was to tell me that Bertolt Brecht would not be proud of me".') (Just....what?)